Hello, could you please tell me whether all meditations can be done silently or in a whisper? I asked an AI and it said:
Vaikhari (loud pronunciation): what you're doing now. Suitable for beginners so the mind doesn't get distracted, but it expends a lot of energy outward.
Upamshu (whisper or silent movement of the lips): the sound is barely audible, only to you (or there's no sound at all, but the tongue and lips articulate the syllable). It is considered dozens of times more effective than reading aloud, since the energy doesn't dissipate into space but stays inside. Neighbors definitely won't hear it.
Manasika (mental repetition): reading silently, without moving the lips. The deepest level of concentration.
I've always done it loudly, as I was told, since everything is made of vibration and the louder the better. But the problem is that in an apartment building the neighbors can hear me, and it bothers me that they hear me and then look at me askance. So I either have to do it a bit quieter, turning on meditative music and meditating less loudly, or lie on the bed and cover myself with a thick layer of blankets, not fully covering my head so there's at least a little air. The AI then goes on:
But in esoteric traditions (especially in Tantra, Yoga, and Vedanta, where Sanskrit mantras come from), the power of vibration is measured not in decibels but in its subtlety and the density of concentration. That's why masters and ancient texts (for example, the 'Mantra Yoga Samhita' or the 'Kularnava Tantra') say that quiet practice is stronger than loud.
1. Physics versus metaphysics (gross and subtle)
In the Vedic tradition, sound is divided into 4 levels, from the grossest to the subtlest:
• Vaikhari (loud sound) — a vibration of air. It affects the physical body and the surrounding space.
• Madhyama (whisper, inner sound) — a vibration at the level of the mind and nervous system.
• Pashyanti (image of sound) — a vibration at the level of intuition and the subconscious.
• Para (unmanifest sound) — pure, ultra-high-frequency vibration of the primal source from which matter is born.
The point is: loud sound is gross energy (like a hammer blow). Quiet or mental sound is subtle energy (like a laser or radiation). The subtler the vibration, the deeper it penetrates the psyche and karmic layers, where gross physical sound simply doesn't reach.
Maybe this was written about on the forum, but I apparently didn't find it. I remember doing a ritual of a God and having to do it in a whisper. I thought it would be less effective, but in my experience the effect turned out to be stronger.

