Why do you not agree on this?
Some resources on the matter.
The power is in the breath. So Thoth said.
The humming breath is the foundation of mantra. It is a basic pranayama you can find on the list of breathing exercises on JoS. The more drawn-out the breath is (WITHOUT STRAINING YOURSELF!)*, the more powerful is your mantra practice. Intent and focus can make up part of this, as some people who are not really ready to use mantra tend to get distracted when vibrating properly. However, in no way you can achieve with fast vibrations as much power as proper vibration done by someone is actually read for mantra (laser focus, full-on intent).
There was a scheme HP HC shared a while ago. I don't remember which topic was this in. It would be great if someone could link it, in order to offer a fuller picture of the HP's post. It went like this, from the most powerful to the least:
:arrow: 1. Full vibrations
:arrow: 2. Fast vibrations
:arrow: 3. Whispered vibrations
:arrow: 4. Mental vibrations
Obviously, the vibration should be of the proper frequency for what you're working, and you will feel it in the specific part of the soul. If it's not the right frequency, you're doing little to nothing at all.
Some time ago you talk in the Italian forum about how I perform vibrations. Personally I can not do a breath for each vibration, rather I do a breath that includes up to 10 15 or 20 small vibrations (speaking of short mantras such as maum, gaum, klim ...) I fully perceive the energy and I get...
ancient-forums.com
----
For point 4 about mispronounciations, what if I'm doing a jupiter square, and while vibrating "Guruave" I try to roll the "R" but the roll doesn't happen, what should I do in this case? I assume the answer would be stop trying to vibrate the word once the roll doesn't happen and try to vibrate...
ancient-forums.com
----
Mantras are powerful tools in the arsenal of any magick practitioner to attain your ends. Words of power are to be chanted and vibrated as it's known by everyone here past the beginner level. Now it appears there are a few things people have wrong about mantras. Mantras are means through which...
ancient-forums.com
Thank you for looking for sources, your help is really appreciated. I would just like to add that I never said in my answer to the topic to vibrate things in the mind or to sit in a meditative position in a disorderly way, etc.
In fact, I limited myself to writing that it is possible to vibrate the mantra by whispering while sitting upright pretending to read. So if someone believes or does not believe that you can vibrate mentally it is not in line with what I wrote, since I limited myself to suggesting to vibrate even simply by whispering while sitting upright.
I never said or dared to support anything else, I want to specify it to ensure the best precision of my answer. The topic was about whether you could use mantras by whispering and avoiding overly obvious meditative positions.
And I replied to this because I do not feel like I have the permission to suggest to someone not to perform certain meditations, if this someone wants, only because it could be more comfortable to do others, the user who posted the topic will surely know other meditations that do not require vibrations, if he wants to vibrate I cannot tell him not to do it since his spiritual program is very personal.
As long as someone does not write to me: "I dedicated myself yesterday and today I want to do 100 breaths of the fire element" or dangerous things of the sort where there it is really my duty as a Satanist to intervene, I absolutely do not feel like telling someone: "do not use mantras".
But there is really no point in arguing about this because we can calmly analyze the opinion of the High Priest HoodedCobra666. Analyze this screenshot I took of this comment:
As you can all see, this brother of ours explains how the rituals can be performed by whispering and one of the likes is from High Priest HoodedCobra666 himself.
Thank you very much for your advice and opinion!
You're welcome. Your situation is complicated, so if you ever need it, don't hesitate to ask.