I think it's pretty common for most people to feel drawn towards something that isn't Abrahamic. For me, I got lucky that I grew up with a mother that was already into ancient wisdom. It wasn't something scary to me.
As life went on, I realized that something was missing in my life. I wanted to better myself. I wanted to achieve my goals. I heard the call from Zeus to come back. I knew that everything I wanted was down this path. Not through empty worship, but through working on myself to reach the Gods.
I have no regrets and will never lose trust in the Gods. They give more than just blessings. They give you knowledge and wisdom.